
The SEC's new guidance says token holders voting on a network generally are not a central party, and separates a working token from a decentralized network.
In brief
- The SEC says token holders voting on a network generally do not count as a central party, unless they are affiliated or act together.
- A party "oversees participation" if it can control access at the protocol, validator or user level.
- The guidance follows the CLARITY Act failing a Senate vote 49 to 50 on 15 September.
What happened
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has added three answers on who controls a crypto network, according to Coin Bureau.
The first says token holders voting on a network generally do not count as a "central party".
The exception is holders who are affiliated or agree to act together.
The second says a central party "oversees participation" if it can control access at the protocol, validator or user level.
The third separates a network being "functional", meaning its token works on it, from being "decentralized", meaning no one controls it.
Why it matters
The test speaks to the decentralization claims of DeFi projects and to how token holders and validators are treated.
A project that markets itself as community-run can still have a central party under the second answer.
That applies if one entity can gate access at the protocol, validator or user level.
Voting by holders is less likely to create that party, unless the holders are linked or coordinate.
The guidance is the SEC's latest crypto move without Congress, per Coin Bureau.
It follows the CLARITY Act failing a Senate vote 49 to 50 on 15 September.
Earlier steps listed by the outlet include a 17 September exemption for trading tokenized US stocks on blockchain venues.
A 25 September crypto FAQ covered how securities laws apply to tokens.
On 1 October came a proposal on how investment advisers and funds can hold crypto.